A while back, I posted about UK immigration policy (this was pre-Brexit, before Brexit was a twinkle in Boris Johnson’s eye, even) and I mooted the idea that our government might be steering the UK towards a lower, and hopefully sustainable, population with a correspondingly smaller economy. Well, recent events suggest that this could be a possibility.
|I attended an event held by GMSS, on “Misrepresenting Reality” – a critique of the information provided by the Leave campaign (most of which turned out to be lies and/or appeals to nostalgia). Well, I say attended, what I mean is that I missed the whole talk but snuck in during the extended Q&A (hey, I have a demanding job).
One of the questions asked of the speaker (who is a Professor in European Law, so they know their stuff) was whether they had heard any good arguments in support of Brexit. They said no, but there was one possibility that no-one has mentioned – that Brexit would result in the UK’s population and economy reducing in size and resulting in a smaller, sustainable nation with comfortable living standards but no aspirations to be anything greater.
Personally, I don’t think that would be a good thing, but it would be an argument that actually held some water, in comparison to jingoistic ranting and slogans painted on buses. It seems that there are decisions happening as to where our country is headed. I see it as being in one of two broad directions:
- Economic growth, high population, high output – We aim to keep producing, innovating, and competing as a first-world player. We take an active role on the world stage, with diplomatic and military influence and an international outlook. In order for this to happen, our infrastructure and population need to consistently grow, and we have to be able to maintain this growth against competitor nations who may have an advantage in terms of efficiency in terms of production and labour costs (I’m looking at you, China and India). High immigration is necessary to bolster the population, due to the below-replacement birth rate of indigenous Brits.
- Declining economy, low population, low output – we accept that other countries will overtake us, and we make the decision to go quietly. We reduce our population by curbing immigration, and continuing with policies designed to discourage people from having large families. We maintain a decent quality of life by relying more on our own industries, with some overseas trade in specialised products and services. We maintain a foothold in international politics, but our role is far less significant. The capacity of our armed services is whittled down even further and take a more ceremonial and/or peacekeeping role.
You may decide that you prefer one or other of those options, or neither, or you might not have any strong feelings on it. But one thing we do know is that this was not the Brexit Britain we were promised. We’re not going to bring The Empire back – and I’m sure there will be many disappointed Leavers who feel they got sold a pup.